We hear that Donald Trump does not believe the CIA and FBI analysis of Russian interference in the recent presidential elections. That has echoes of the experience many of us had with the erstwhile Chief Executive of Natural England.
In 2006, we rapidly got to realise that our CEO did not trust us. We frequently heard about meetings between the CEO and 'partner' organisations from our counterparts in said organisation. We had no firm clue about what was said and agreed (you cannot always trust your counterparts if they spot a weakness in your intelligence systems). Our CEO announced that we would be' told what we needed to know'! We had no firm idea about what our policy should be - try writing a policy paper with the instruction 'I'll know what I want when I see it'! Worse still, we had no clue about the information that would actually be valued by the CEO. Needless to say, this relationship was accompanied by an exodus of technical skills that have been lost for ever. It does not take a lot to kill off the relationship between management and the troops on point duty. Why stick your neck out if the Chief is as likely to chop it off than the opposition might seek to do!
If I was a member of the CIA or FBI I would be very worried. If the Chief does not trust you, and won't take briefings other than on an intermittent basis, you are in serious trouble. I always took the view that one should at least listen to the troops on point duty - they have the most relevant experience and are the eyes and ears of the organisation. If you don't trust them, then you are exposing the whole army (country/organisation) to acting blind.
God help the western World!
This blog is a commentary on important countryside management issues as and when they arise. My intention is to provide a reflective view of such issues in a manner that hopefully emphasises the strategic rather than the knee-jerk implications of particular events.
Tuesday, 13 December 2016
Wednesday, 7 December 2016
A future for mankind
President-elect Donald Trump's appointment of Scott Pruitt to lead the US Environmental Protection Agency should be greeted with delight by those of us who believe in Gaia Theory.
True, both Trump and Pruitt are climate-change deniers. But then, they also have no respect for science, so there is precious little point in the scientific community getting very exercised about the political change. Realistically, Trump represents the view of at least 50% of the western World and probably closer to 70% of that World. I rarely come across people who really believe in climate change. Often, they argue that sea level rise is not happening, that the climate has always changed, and that there is no proof that humankind has changed the climate. It is a view that will be embraced by most people because the alternatives are pretty unpalatable.
Do we want to face up to reality and take action that will hurt us, or should we bury our heads in the sand and wait to be kicked up the behind by something rather unpleasant? In reality it is not my generation that will face the biggest kick up the backside. It is the next generation: my friend's children and grand children. My sadness is for them.
Nevertheless, the sooner that climate change kicks us hard, the better. That way, perhaps mankind will start to die out. Sadly, many of the iconic plants and animals that currently exist will also be lost. BUT, I take comfort from the 'Great Permian Extinction' and from the K-T event that led to the demise of the Dinosaurs. If mankind is eliminated, the world in 10 million years time could be a fantastic place. Donald Trump will be an irrelevance and mankind just a narrow footnote in history. Most of the major epochs lasted tens of millions of years but the Anthropocene may well last less than 10,000 years - a minor footnote in history! Should we care? Yes, because we love our decendents but no if we care more about the long-term possibilities for the World.
Saturday, 8 October 2016
Do statutory bodies have a responsibility for countryside management?
A bit of history
My view of organisations passing responsibility to voluntary
sector were greatly influenced by experience when I became Conservation Officer
for South Humberside back in 1994. It was a baptism by fire for me. I arrived
to find that the leadership team in Wakefield had decided to withdraw funding
for the Humber Wildfowl Refuge. Until that time English Nature had employed a warden on behalf of the Refuge Committee. The cessation of funding coincided
with my arrival and caused mayhem. My first year or more was occupied trying to
find alternative funding streams. I was accused by some in the Refuge Committee
of being incompetent because I was not fighting off the move - by the time I
arrived it was a fait accompli but somebody had to be blamed.
Leadership suggestions were that the Refuge Committee should
look for alternative funding sources such as sponsorship. That was a big 'ask'
and as the nominated secretary to the Refuge Committee I found that much of the
work fell to me (part of my EN job). I put in vast numbers of hours attending
evening meetings and drew comments from my line manager that I should not be
doing such levels of work. I was threatened a reduced (performance) box marking at the end
of the year if I did not cut my hours. Not much chance of that - I still had to
achieve my performance agreement, which included sorting out the Refuge
Committee problems. So my workload management failed completely! We never did
find sponsorship for wardening but did find funds for other projects that
required yet more work from me to manage the projects.
Lesson 1. I've
never forgotten that experience and the lessons it conveyed. Anybody that
thinks you can replace long-term funding for maintenance of an organisation or
site forgets that sponsors need some big sound bites. Project funding explicitly
excludes maintenance of the fabric that makes a project possible. So do not
fall for the idea that you can replace long-term funding by 'sponsorship' - to
do that you will have to spend a lot more of staff to raise funds to keep their
jobs going and maybe provide a surplus to do some worthy projects.
A parallel experience
Later on, I found myself picking up the pieces when English
Nature's Estuaries Initiative was drawing to a close. This was a 'pump-priming
project that had a clearly defined timeframe for funding. It was always the
case that funding would diminish. I arrived in post to find that the funds were
rapidly dropping and an alternative funding stream was needed; does that sound
familiar! A study was commissioned to look at the value of Estuary Partnerships.
I, and several others felt that if funding was to be maintained there was a
need for the partnerships to have some clear evidence of the benefits that employing
a project officer brought to the funding bodies (including EN). I've never forgotten
the English Coastal Partnerships meeting in Dorset when Pete Barham and I were
met with vocal comments - here are the men who want to close down Estuary
Partnerships. How wrong they were, but we did want them to actually understand that funding organisations need some tangible evidence of what they will loose if they stop funding.
Some of the Partnerships have survived because they were
genuinely needed. Others, perhaps because of the skills of their project
officer finding funding initiatives - often European projects. Yet, over time
their numbers have dwindled. Not that long ago, Natural England cut the last
funding route - European Marine Site management.
Lesson 2 - don't
set up pump-priming projects - they will turn round and bite you! Likewise, don't think your withdrawal from funding will not convey a clear message that you are no longer committed. If you
work on a project, please recognise that it is a project and not mainstream -
thus you will always be vulnerable to funding cuts. Those cuts will be
decisions by more senior people than the manager of the initiative who will
probably have little or no say in the outcome.
Modern parallels
I was therefore very surprised when Surrey Wildlife Trust
took on management of Chobham Common and other Nature Reserves on behalf of
Surrey County Council. I thought it was a brave move by the Trust and suspected
they would get caught by removal of funding some time later. I gather that this
is now happening and that the Council is doing what happened to me - passing
responsibility to the Trust and removing the agreed funding stream and
suggesting that funds be sourced from 'sponsorship'. There is a big lesson to
be learned from this experience!
Lesson 3: Beware
the gifts that carry a funding stream that can be cut!
Moving on to issues closer to me. I have had an interest in
Mitcham Common ever since I could walk. It was my playground as a child and was
instrumental in the early development of my science 'skills'. Until the late
1970s the Common had very limited funds, even though three Local Authorities
(Croydon, Merton and Sutton) were required by law to maintain the common on
behalf of the communities they served. The 'Conservators' response was to use
the common as a tip - gaining a significant investment opportunity and
establishing a pot of money that provides a diminishing investment return. It
was not the first time that the common had been used as a tip - there are
several low-lying tips of domestic rubbish and one huge one - that accommodated
the rubbish of the London Borough of Croydon for several years - at zero cost
to the Council!
Today, we find that both Croydon and Sutton Councils are
reducing or ceasing their contributions that fund staff to keep the common in good order for the
enjoyment of local people. There is a serious risk that Local Authority funding
streams will stop completely. Current funding levels are really insufficient to
maintain the common - scrub has advanced inexorably, despite lots of action by
the wardening team and volunteers. In recent years there has been additional
funding under the Higher Level Stewardship Scheme - effectively EU funding.
That funding stream is also threatened by Brexit. Whilst it would be nice to
think that such schemes will be maintained after Brexit, the track
record of Governments and Local Authorities is very dubious based on my past experience.
Lesson 4: Do not
believe that statutory responsibility means that funding cannot or will not be
cut. It can, and it happens with frightening regularity. It is all a matter of
priorities.
So, from these lessons, I urge the 'Friends of Mitcham
Common' to put pressure on the three Local Authorities (Croydon, Sutton and
Merton) to recognise that the common is a fantastic resource for the peoples of
the three Boroughs. It cannot be maintained by voluntary effort alone; nor can
it be resourced by project funding.
Saturday, 17 September 2016
State of Nature report
On Wednesday the latest 'State of Nature' report was published. It got good press on the Radio that morning - I listened as I prepared to leave for a Workshop in Germany. The message is hardly surprising - some species are expanding their range/recovering, but rather more are declining. The biggest declines, inevitably, are amongst invertebrates and plants, whilst the most prominent gains seem to be amongst vertebrates. Why should anybody be surprised?
On the plus side, we are still seeing the bounce-back from the effects of DDT on predatory birds. Coupled with a decline in persecution of raptors in some areas, this change in land management has to be welcomed. It is noteworthy, however, that the agricultural sector is highlighting the improvement as a significant reason for a decline in other species! And, of course there are lobbies to reverse the improvements - badger culls and buzzard culls are just two initiatives; calls for a cull of sparrowhawks is another! So, I guess as part of the new Conservative administration's programme we might well see measures to reverse the trend in wildlife recovery!
The other gains are not necessarily positive. In my experience, gains are happening amongst introduced species, some of which are pests and others are simply establishing as part of the background mesh of wildlife. Other gains are happening where species at the edge of range are improving their foothold as clime change affects the landscape. Whilst such improvements are to be welcomed, we should perhaps treat them with some caution.
So, I will be accused of having a glass half empty! Well let that be so. I recall parts of the 'leadership' of my erstwhile employers saying 'I don't want to hear about problems I simply want the good news'. The same holds with the NFU response - the NGOs should have been crowing about successes and brushing the declines under the table.
Well, I for one hope that the NGOs will continue to highlight the problems. In my experience they lie primarily amongst the specialist species and paint a very worrying picture of wildlife's future. The State of Nature report particularly highlights problems with invertebrates, which on the basis of my field experience I think is correct.
The State of Nature report is actually reasonably balanced. It does highlight changing agricultural practice, but then it also highlights the role a changing climate can play. As always, there will be gains and losses, and different people will lay the blame primarily on one factor. Placing emphasis on a particular cause is an easy way out but it won't solve the problem.
Using the NFU argument, if raptor numbers are increasing we should expect to see a diminution of prey items. That is a good theory, but it starts to fall apart as one travels down the food chain. Perhaps a case could be developed to link declines in smaller birds and mammals to increased raptor numbers? But, I don't think the data are telling us this. The loss of a favourite blackbird from the bird table is a visible expression of nature red in tooth and claw, but it does not mean that there is a problem with raptors. Large-scale losses in farmland birds have not been accompanied by vast increases in sparrowhawk numbers. The scale of sparrowhawk increases would have had to have been much greater to have resulted in the scale of declines in farmland birds. Moreover, the declines in farmland birds started well before a significant increase in sparrowhawks was detectable.
It is invertebrates that are perhaps the best indicators. If the NFU argument was correct, then by rights we should be seen huge increases in invertebrate populations as bird predation diminishes with the decline in their numbers. Sadly, that is not the case. When did you last have to clear your windscreen of splatted insects? When did you last drive through clouds of moths on a balmy summer's evening? I don't remember the last time I saw large numbers of ghost swift moths over a grassland, yet there are plenty of grasslands and the site where I used to see them still exists.
So, I am sorry NFU, you cannot deflect the blame onto 'predators'. nor can you duck the issue by asking that we accentuate the positives and brush the bad news under the carpet.
I must depart from the accepted mantra is that the problem primarily lies with changing agriculture. I agree that this is a significant issue, but my instincts and experience suggest that other factors are at work too.
Extreme weather, especially major droughts and exceptionally warm winters, is possibly a far more important influence on our NATIVE wildlife. I would put to one side those at the extreme of range, whose fortune wax and wane with the climate. My feeling is that it is far more important to focus on species that are primarily associated with the equable Atlantic climate. Chilly winters and warm wet summers.
Short warm winters such as that of 2015/16 mean that species adapted to longer cold conditions will not be able to survive and will shift to their favoured climate envelope (more northerly and western). Meanwhile, those species that rely on wet conditions will fail if there are prolonged droughts. There have been several major droughts in the past 30 years, starting with 1976/77, followed by a similar event in the early 1990s and again in the mid-1990s, and then again in the early 2000s. Each time, the wetland assemblage took a hammering and as far as I can see parts of it have never recovered. Good indicators might be the craneflies and snail-killing flies, but the data just are not robust enough to work from. Hoverfly data certainly point to drought as an important factor.
My feeling is that climate change is a very significant factor, but that we should not lose sight of the other big concern: loss of the fabric of the countryside as hedgerows and ditches are cleared and field sizes have been vastly increased. Loss of mixed farms and concentration on bigger areas of just a few crops cannot be positive. Landscape heterogeneity is a major factor in the overall abundance of wildlife, but the loss of unusual habitats such as seepages, log jams, wet soils and semi-permanent water bodies is equally significant.
So, NFU, I cannot let you off the hook, but the problems are much broader and these were properly discussed in the State of Nature report.
The positive message?
On the plus side, we are still seeing the bounce-back from the effects of DDT on predatory birds. Coupled with a decline in persecution of raptors in some areas, this change in land management has to be welcomed. It is noteworthy, however, that the agricultural sector is highlighting the improvement as a significant reason for a decline in other species! And, of course there are lobbies to reverse the improvements - badger culls and buzzard culls are just two initiatives; calls for a cull of sparrowhawks is another! So, I guess as part of the new Conservative administration's programme we might well see measures to reverse the trend in wildlife recovery!
The other gains are not necessarily positive. In my experience, gains are happening amongst introduced species, some of which are pests and others are simply establishing as part of the background mesh of wildlife. Other gains are happening where species at the edge of range are improving their foothold as clime change affects the landscape. Whilst such improvements are to be welcomed, we should perhaps treat them with some caution.
there is always a 'but' ....
So, I will be accused of having a glass half empty! Well let that be so. I recall parts of the 'leadership' of my erstwhile employers saying 'I don't want to hear about problems I simply want the good news'. The same holds with the NFU response - the NGOs should have been crowing about successes and brushing the declines under the table.
Well, I for one hope that the NGOs will continue to highlight the problems. In my experience they lie primarily amongst the specialist species and paint a very worrying picture of wildlife's future. The State of Nature report particularly highlights problems with invertebrates, which on the basis of my field experience I think is correct.
A balanced view of why?
The State of Nature report is actually reasonably balanced. It does highlight changing agricultural practice, but then it also highlights the role a changing climate can play. As always, there will be gains and losses, and different people will lay the blame primarily on one factor. Placing emphasis on a particular cause is an easy way out but it won't solve the problem.
Using the NFU argument, if raptor numbers are increasing we should expect to see a diminution of prey items. That is a good theory, but it starts to fall apart as one travels down the food chain. Perhaps a case could be developed to link declines in smaller birds and mammals to increased raptor numbers? But, I don't think the data are telling us this. The loss of a favourite blackbird from the bird table is a visible expression of nature red in tooth and claw, but it does not mean that there is a problem with raptors. Large-scale losses in farmland birds have not been accompanied by vast increases in sparrowhawk numbers. The scale of sparrowhawk increases would have had to have been much greater to have resulted in the scale of declines in farmland birds. Moreover, the declines in farmland birds started well before a significant increase in sparrowhawks was detectable.
It is invertebrates that are perhaps the best indicators. If the NFU argument was correct, then by rights we should be seen huge increases in invertebrate populations as bird predation diminishes with the decline in their numbers. Sadly, that is not the case. When did you last have to clear your windscreen of splatted insects? When did you last drive through clouds of moths on a balmy summer's evening? I don't remember the last time I saw large numbers of ghost swift moths over a grassland, yet there are plenty of grasslands and the site where I used to see them still exists.
So, I am sorry NFU, you cannot deflect the blame onto 'predators'. nor can you duck the issue by asking that we accentuate the positives and brush the bad news under the carpet.
But who is to blame?
I must depart from the accepted mantra is that the problem primarily lies with changing agriculture. I agree that this is a significant issue, but my instincts and experience suggest that other factors are at work too.
Extreme weather, especially major droughts and exceptionally warm winters, is possibly a far more important influence on our NATIVE wildlife. I would put to one side those at the extreme of range, whose fortune wax and wane with the climate. My feeling is that it is far more important to focus on species that are primarily associated with the equable Atlantic climate. Chilly winters and warm wet summers.
Short warm winters such as that of 2015/16 mean that species adapted to longer cold conditions will not be able to survive and will shift to their favoured climate envelope (more northerly and western). Meanwhile, those species that rely on wet conditions will fail if there are prolonged droughts. There have been several major droughts in the past 30 years, starting with 1976/77, followed by a similar event in the early 1990s and again in the mid-1990s, and then again in the early 2000s. Each time, the wetland assemblage took a hammering and as far as I can see parts of it have never recovered. Good indicators might be the craneflies and snail-killing flies, but the data just are not robust enough to work from. Hoverfly data certainly point to drought as an important factor.
My feeling is that climate change is a very significant factor, but that we should not lose sight of the other big concern: loss of the fabric of the countryside as hedgerows and ditches are cleared and field sizes have been vastly increased. Loss of mixed farms and concentration on bigger areas of just a few crops cannot be positive. Landscape heterogeneity is a major factor in the overall abundance of wildlife, but the loss of unusual habitats such as seepages, log jams, wet soils and semi-permanent water bodies is equally significant.
So, NFU, I cannot let you off the hook, but the problems are much broader and these were properly discussed in the State of Nature report.
Saturday, 10 September 2016
It seems I must blame Golf for my lack of work overseas!
Oh what fun! I find it really amusing to hear Dr Liam Fox's views
on what is wrong with British Industry! It strikes me that he completely fails
to understand what drives industry. Perhaps the following would be a useful
insight for him as to why I am not chasing business deals in the Far East:
There may be opportunities in some parts of
the Far East, but there are some obvious impediments to progress by smaller
businesses:
- Lack of contacts
- Cost of travel
- The need for visas
- Lack of language skills
- Lack of a clear understanding of what might be marketable
- Why should developing nations use overseas specialists when they have their own specialists in up-and-coming universities.
I am
part of the UK service industry, which a massive part of UK exports but is dismissed as irrelevant by
the Brexiteers - all they seem to see as UK industry is widget-makers. Unfortunately, I also work in a business area where most of Government spending
is wrapped up in call-off contracts with the biggest consultancies. As such there is
precious little chance of making a solid income, let alone one where there is
sufficient money to invest in speculative travel to suitable venues. I get innumerable invitations to conferences in China, Thailand and
goodness knows where else, but I simply cannot afford the costs - one needs a strong income to support speculative travel. Therefore, I am sorry to say that I won't be contributing more to the UK export drive.
My main overseas market is/was northern Europe - which is
fast slipping away from me as Brexit makes it less likely that my services will
be wanted - who in Europe will want a consultant from a country that has stuck
two fingers up at them and the legislation that I specialise in?
So, wake up Brexiteers - you have destroyed one market for
the UK service industry and have placed your faith in doing business in parts
of the world where their labour costs are lower. Whilst they may speak
English we don't have a clue what they are saying - we are very definitely on
the back foot. So, maybe a few parts of business do put more emphasis on their
golf handicap but I suspect those businesses that can secure overseas markets
have already done so. The service industry best placed to secure these markets is already there - American-owned giants with British outposts. I saw no evidence presented by Brexiteers of any market
research that really showed that there was this gaping market for British
goods.
Me thinks this is the start of the chickens coming home to
roost.
Friday, 24 June 2016
So the Lemmings have jumped off the cliff
I am not surprised by the result this morning; nor am I too surprised by the crash in the Pound. According to the Brext camp this was not going to happen!
I wonder what else of the warnings made by the remain team will come true? I hope the most serious do not, but suspect that they will. A run on the Pound may well precipitate a rise in interest rates. If, as Standard and Poor have said, the UK's AAA rating is lost, then that too indicates that rates will have to rise. Meanwhile, a 10% drop in the Pound must mean an increase in prices, especially of fuel and imported commodities and food. Likewise, other imported goods will rise in price
So, at last, inflation will start to re-emerge as an economic shadow. For the saver reliant on interest rates to provide an income that may well be no bad thing, but for home owners with big mortgages that is a real shadow on the horizon. If rates rise significantly there is quite a serious risk of a rise in mortgage defaults and a decline in house prices. Maybe such a decline would be a good thing, but the economy is frightfully closely linked to house prices, so I think the chances of us avoiding another recession in the near future are diminishing.
As Sir John Major commented just a couple of days ago, a Brexit vote will mean that the chickens will come home to roost for those in the leave camp who so rubbished Remain's economic concerns. I cannot see how David Cameron can continue as PM, especially given the calls for George Osborne's head. Both Cameron and Osborne subscribed to the same economic predictions and Cameron can hardly sack Osborne and keep his reputation for being a man of principle - blaming the cook when the butler has spiked the curry is not the done thing!
Well, I guess those of us with business interests linked to European legislation had best look for an alternative job. As things stand, I think my company will have to fold in the next 18 months; who in China or India will want my services?
I wonder what else of the warnings made by the remain team will come true? I hope the most serious do not, but suspect that they will. A run on the Pound may well precipitate a rise in interest rates. If, as Standard and Poor have said, the UK's AAA rating is lost, then that too indicates that rates will have to rise. Meanwhile, a 10% drop in the Pound must mean an increase in prices, especially of fuel and imported commodities and food. Likewise, other imported goods will rise in price
So, at last, inflation will start to re-emerge as an economic shadow. For the saver reliant on interest rates to provide an income that may well be no bad thing, but for home owners with big mortgages that is a real shadow on the horizon. If rates rise significantly there is quite a serious risk of a rise in mortgage defaults and a decline in house prices. Maybe such a decline would be a good thing, but the economy is frightfully closely linked to house prices, so I think the chances of us avoiding another recession in the near future are diminishing.
As Sir John Major commented just a couple of days ago, a Brexit vote will mean that the chickens will come home to roost for those in the leave camp who so rubbished Remain's economic concerns. I cannot see how David Cameron can continue as PM, especially given the calls for George Osborne's head. Both Cameron and Osborne subscribed to the same economic predictions and Cameron can hardly sack Osborne and keep his reputation for being a man of principle - blaming the cook when the butler has spiked the curry is not the done thing!
Well, I guess those of us with business interests linked to European legislation had best look for an alternative job. As things stand, I think my company will have to fold in the next 18 months; who in China or India will want my services?
Monday, 13 June 2016
At last a sensible man!
Andrew Tyrie's article in The Times today hit the spot for me. At last there was an analysis that was not filled with the hot air of Brexit or the open goals created by the Remain campaign. It was measured and sensible. Of course Brexit will rubbish it because his conclusion was in favour of 'Remain', but there is no escaping the fact that the Brexit camp have told a pack of lies in all sorts of places; from mis-quoting figures on the UK contribution, to spreading fear about an imminent influx of Turkish immigrants. Brexit talk 'project fear' but I think the same or worse charges can be levelled at them.
Meanwhile, the financial markets are already getting the jitters. The Pound is down to April levels and levels of uncertainty about the UK economy are rising. That means that whatever happens on June 23rd, the economy is being affected by fears of Brexit. We can only speculate what will happen when a concern becomes a reality. A Sterling crash will of course mean that lots of British holidaymakers will pay a lot more for their 'sun, sand and Sangria', but also that perhaps our tourist industry will get a boost and guest house rates will rise so that Brits cannot afford them! A double whammy!
For me, the more worrying issue is the impact of a dip in share prices will have on people's pension schemes. For those in the 55-65 bracket there are good grounds to be very worried. If you have a money purchase scheme expect your investments to yield a much lower return and therefore any pension to be substantially lower. If you are below 40, pile the money in now as there is a chance you will do better than you might otherwise have done (in 25-30 years time).
It does not stop there. We have already seen the impact of a deficit in the pension scheme and its effect on the future of a business. The 'British Steel' situation is salutary, whilst the BHS debacle should send a shockwave through remaining pension schemes with significant deficits and a lack of a decent commitment to a recovery plan. If your scheme is a defined benefits scheme that has not closed, expect it to close to new entrants in the very near future - big holes in such schemes mean that action has to be taken and one start of the process is to close to new entrants.
Of course, to use James Dyson's words I am speaking 'cobblers' if you subscribe to the Brixit argument. Maybe my message is 'project fear'; but I challenge the Brexiteers to resolve a basic problem: almost all economists and commentators expect Brexit to result in a substantial economic shock to the British and possibly the World economy. That will have an impact on current employment, on short-term investment and on the status of pension schemes. By way of an example, I have shares in 'Good Energy' who are floating a rights issue at the moment - do I invest or should I be wary in the face of Brexit and a change in leadership from climate change receptive to climate change deniers? I am wavering but am certain that I will not make any investment at the level I might otherwise have done. My brother goes one stage further and will not invest.
The Brexit camp has brushed over such issues in a most cavalier manner but it cannot surely ignore the economic facts of life when economies shrink: there is less money in the exchequer, less money invested and fewer jobs created. There WILL be a short- to medium-term impact after Brexit and some of that impact WILL have long-term consequences for people approaching their pension. Forget the question of whether the Government pension will continue to be pegged to inflation; private pensions will not be pegged in quite the same way - they are linked to real-time economic performance. We cannot be sure how any future Government will deal with a hole in the budget, but if it is the right wing of the Conservative Party you can bet that they will be prepared to consider what they argue is unthinkable - there will have to be cuts somewhere as they will not raise taxes.
So, my question to the Brexit camp - will you be using the savings from Brexit to supplement those who lose out when their pension pot drops because UK share prices trip up? I'll bet there won't be enough in the kitty after all their rash promises have been fulfilled.
Meanwhile, the financial markets are already getting the jitters. The Pound is down to April levels and levels of uncertainty about the UK economy are rising. That means that whatever happens on June 23rd, the economy is being affected by fears of Brexit. We can only speculate what will happen when a concern becomes a reality. A Sterling crash will of course mean that lots of British holidaymakers will pay a lot more for their 'sun, sand and Sangria', but also that perhaps our tourist industry will get a boost and guest house rates will rise so that Brits cannot afford them! A double whammy!
For me, the more worrying issue is the impact of a dip in share prices will have on people's pension schemes. For those in the 55-65 bracket there are good grounds to be very worried. If you have a money purchase scheme expect your investments to yield a much lower return and therefore any pension to be substantially lower. If you are below 40, pile the money in now as there is a chance you will do better than you might otherwise have done (in 25-30 years time).
It does not stop there. We have already seen the impact of a deficit in the pension scheme and its effect on the future of a business. The 'British Steel' situation is salutary, whilst the BHS debacle should send a shockwave through remaining pension schemes with significant deficits and a lack of a decent commitment to a recovery plan. If your scheme is a defined benefits scheme that has not closed, expect it to close to new entrants in the very near future - big holes in such schemes mean that action has to be taken and one start of the process is to close to new entrants.
Of course, to use James Dyson's words I am speaking 'cobblers' if you subscribe to the Brixit argument. Maybe my message is 'project fear'; but I challenge the Brexiteers to resolve a basic problem: almost all economists and commentators expect Brexit to result in a substantial economic shock to the British and possibly the World economy. That will have an impact on current employment, on short-term investment and on the status of pension schemes. By way of an example, I have shares in 'Good Energy' who are floating a rights issue at the moment - do I invest or should I be wary in the face of Brexit and a change in leadership from climate change receptive to climate change deniers? I am wavering but am certain that I will not make any investment at the level I might otherwise have done. My brother goes one stage further and will not invest.
The Brexit camp has brushed over such issues in a most cavalier manner but it cannot surely ignore the economic facts of life when economies shrink: there is less money in the exchequer, less money invested and fewer jobs created. There WILL be a short- to medium-term impact after Brexit and some of that impact WILL have long-term consequences for people approaching their pension. Forget the question of whether the Government pension will continue to be pegged to inflation; private pensions will not be pegged in quite the same way - they are linked to real-time economic performance. We cannot be sure how any future Government will deal with a hole in the budget, but if it is the right wing of the Conservative Party you can bet that they will be prepared to consider what they argue is unthinkable - there will have to be cuts somewhere as they will not raise taxes.
So, my question to the Brexit camp - will you be using the savings from Brexit to supplement those who lose out when their pension pot drops because UK share prices trip up? I'll bet there won't be enough in the kitty after all their rash promises have been fulfilled.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)